Best Pagan Dating Sites Online

Let’s talk about what makes a Pagan couple lucky in love.

Some of the biggest keys to relationship success are easy to guess: financial compatibility, shared future goals, consensus on whether to have children, and similar values, are all essential building blocks for a lasting union.

Similar values are particularly important, with research showing that religious beliefs rank as high as adequate income as a predictor of long-term marital happiness.

Now let’s imagine you’re one of the approximately 340,000 pagans living in the United States today. In a country with a population of over 30 million, that quantity is a drop in the bucket.

Fortunately, the rising popularity of online dating makes it easier than ever for pagans seeking a soulmate to find their perfect match!

​Top 10 ​Pagan Dating Sites

#​1: eHarmony


Since 2000, eHarmony has been the mainstay of online dating sites. Though many associate the brand with conservative Christianity thanks to its former CEO’s personal viewpoints, eHarmony has undergone a dramatic transformation since its inception and now offers matching services to same-sex couples.


Because of its scope and higher-than-average standards for membership, eHarmony is a wonderful resource for pagans looking for something more than a casual encounter.


Several other noteworthy features set eHarmony apart from its competitors.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​One of the most sophisticated matchmaking algorithms found in online dating.
  • ​​A more rigorous vetting process. Because eHarmony aims to facilitate lasting, long-term relationships, it rejects around 20% of applicants, weeding out those whose answers reflect an interest in hookups.
  • ​​Over 4 million unique hits each month make eHarmony one of the biggest digital dating pools in existence!

If you’re looking for a dating site experience that centers spirituality in a way that eHarmony and Match don’t, look no further than Spiritual Singles. Advertising itself as “a truly conscious, loving dating environment,” Spiritual Singles is open to people of all faiths, sexual orientations, and relationship types.


If you struggle to find a partner who shares your passion for conscious living and ecology, Spiritual Singles may offer exactly the help you need.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Spiritual Singles is part of the Conscious Dating Network, an almost 20-year-old cohort of online dating sites oriented around spirituality and environmental consciousness. Joining any CDN site makes you searchable on any affiliate site, thereby enlarging your pool of prospective partners!
  • ​It caters to those who value permaculture, yoga, sustainable living, alternative news, meditation, and organic nutrition.
  • ​Unlike other dating sites that are oriented exclusively around monogamy, Spiritual Singles is inclusive of polyamorous relationships.

#​​3: ​​Elite Singles


Though pagans aren’t the target demographic of Elite Singles, there’s still plenty this dating site has to offer. Elite Singles was designed with mature, educated users in mind, so pagans with a scholarly streak will feel right at home.


Though pagans aren’t the target demographic of Elite Singles, there’s still plenty this dating site has to offer. Elite Singles was designed with mature, educated users in mind, so pagans with a scholarly streak will feel right at home.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Over 80% of Elite Singles’ users have either a bachelor’s, master’s, or doctorate degree. You’ll never have to worry about being overlooked by matches who feel out of their depth with you!
  • ​More than 165,000 new members sign up for Elite Singles each month, and it gets 2 million monthly page views from well-educated, intelligent professionals.
  • ​The majority of its members are over 30, so those who are looking to make a deeper commitment won’t have to worry about being led on by those who are only seeking casual encounters.

#​4: Match


​Founded in 1995, Match is one of the OG dating sites. It holds the distinction of having led to more relationships than any other online dating platform, and it frequently occupies the #1 position in lists of the best dating sites.


The basic version is free to use and never expires


Match has withstood the test of time and has a success rate equal to its longevity, and that alone makes it worth exploring for Pagans.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Mature users will be pleased to learn Match’s 50+ demographic is its fastest-growing category.
  • ​Its new AskMatch service helps users improve their odds of finding lasting love through one-on-one coaching sessions.
  • ​The site is accessible in 24 different countries, making it possible for pagans to connect with each other all around the world.

Pagan Singles Dating is unlike most of the other sites on this list in that it’s structured more like a social media platform than a traditional online dating service.


This lends it a more casual vibe than other sites and leaves room to form platonic friendships as well as love matches.


If you’re tired of filling out compatibility surveys and you’re ready to try something different, give Pagan Singles Dating a shot. Worst-case scenario, you’ll probably make some great new friends!

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Pagan Singles Dating is part of the CDN, making it an affiliate of Spiritual Singles and many other similar sites.
  • ​Because it has a strong female user base, Pagan Singles Dating favors those who are interested in dating women.
  • ​Unlike algorithm-based dating sites, Pagan Singles Dating relies on communication between users, potentially laying the groundwork for more intimate connections to flourish.

Pagan Dating Site makes it easy – and free! – to sign up, so within minutes you can start connecting with like-minded individuals anywhere in the Conscious Dating Network.


Though it’s one of the smaller sites on this list, Pagan Dating Site is an affiliate of the CDN, so membership means you can cast a wide net among people who value spirituality as much as you do.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Members can search for any type of relationship they desire (men seeking women, women seeking women, etc.).
  • ​Free and paid levels of membership make Pagan Dating Site accessible to users of all incomes.
  • ​International membership allows users to connect with other pagans the world over.

Pagan Dating Service is another departure from the standard online dating template in that it’s a platform for users to find romantic partners as well as partners in spiritual practice.


Whether you’re looking for love or just a larger pagan community, there’s something here for you.


And because it’s part of the CDN, Pagan Dating Service makes it possible for you to connect with other spiritually minded folks all over the world.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Pagan Dating Service states that it serves “Druids, Shamans, Wiccans, Heathens, Odinists or Sacred ecologists.” Whatever path you walk, you’ll be welcome there!
  • ​Members can search for matches based on location, relationship type, and mutual interests.
  • ​All sexual orientations are welcome.

Let’s not forget our friends across the pond! The United Kingdom has a rich history steeped in pagan tradition and folklore. 


Whether you’re based in the UK or just looking for a partner with a sexy accent, Pagan Dating UK is here for you.


Pagan Dating UK takes the pressure off finding a mate and eliminates the obstacle of geography in obtaining lasting love.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​No-frills interface makes the site easy to navigate and streamlines the process of setting up an account.
  • It’s communication-based, so you don’t have to fill out lots of surveys to start finding matches. All you have to do is strike up a conversation.
  • ​Search tools allow you to search for other pagans specific to your region – a special advantage for those living in small and/or conservative communities.

Our list wouldn’t be complete without a site serving Irish pagans! This location-specific dating site was designed exclusively with Irish users in mind, and it offers plenty of perks.


If you’re an Irish citizen looking for a pagan love interest, or even just new friends who share your spiritual persuasions, Pagan Dating Ireland will have what you need.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Inclusivity of all sexual orientations.
  • ​Search tools that allow users to search for matches in their location.
  • ​Affiliation with the CDN, affording users a larger pool of partners and pen-friends to choose from.

Pagan Partners USA is a companion site to Pagan Dating UK, and it’s known by its users for its friendliness and open-mindedness.


If you’re turned off by the “meat market” quality of other dating sites, Pagan Partners USA lets you form more personal, meaningful connections.

​BEST FEATURES

  • ​Because its biggest priority is spiritual compatibility, users don’t need to worry that they won’t fit into a particular age demographic. Pagan Partners USA serves people of all ages and from all walks of life!
  • ​The “meeting page” format makes it possible to find friends as well as romantic interests and takes off some of the pressure when meeting new people.
  • ​Pagan Partners USA is free to use!

Conclusion & Final Thoughts


Belonging to an alternative spiritual path can feel lonely at times, especially if you happen to live in a smaller community with little diversity of belief.


Fortunately, online dating has made it easier than ever for you to find friendship, love, and common ground with people who share your beliefs. 

So what are you waiting for? Sign up and you may soon discover that romance is only a click away!


Join The Discussion